Electronic monitoring not an alternative to immigration detention
Harsha Walia and Syed Hussan
A coroner’s inquiry is taking place in Vancouver this week on Lucia Vega Jimenez’s suicide in Canadian Border Service Agency (CBSA) custody.
Immigration detainees are also on strike in Ontario, and a Red Cross investigation of CBSA facilities – described as dungeons by some lawyers – has just come to light. The Red Cross found over-crowding, inadequate mental health supports, a lack of support for detained children, and presence of mold in detention cells. Many of these shortcomings constitute a failure to comply with national and international standards.
For the first time in a long time, immigration detention is getting the scrutiny it deserves. In response, CBSA is trying to change tracks. Its most recent move is introducing the idea of electronic monitoring systems as an alternative to immigration detention.
As community members that work closely with immigration detainees, we believe electronic monitoring is not a just alternative to immigrant detention.